Prior authorization is approval based on a plan's specific requirements, given before your drug plan will cover a prescription. Step therapy is one kind: a type of prior authorization that requires you first to try a certain, less expensive drug. The request comes from your eye doctor's office, with the diagnosis and the reasons for the drug. In a Medicare drug plan, the plan must decide within 72 hours after receiving a standard request, or 24 hours for an urgent one. If the answer is no, you can appeal, and with most private plans an outside reviewer can overturn it: your insurer is required by law to accept the external reviewer's decision. Our office handles these requests for prescription eye drops.
Key takeaways
- Prior authorization is a plan's approval before it covers a prescription, and step therapy asks you to try a cheaper drug first.
- A Medicare drug plan must decide a standard request within 72 hours and an urgent one within 24 hours.
- After a denial you can appeal within 180 days, and an outside reviewer's decision binds most private plans.
- If your eye is painful, red and getting worse while you wait on a plan, call your eye doctor the same day, or go to an emergency room when closed.
01
What is prior authorization for eye drops?
It's your plan's sign-off before it pays for a drug. Medicare defines it as approval based on a plan's specific requirements, and private plans use the same idea. Which drops need it depends on your plan's drug list, so the same drop can need approval on one plan and not on another.
Plans have a few related rules, and Medicare lists them together:
- Prior authorization: approval before the plan covers the drug.
- Step therapy: a type of prior authorization that requires you first to try a certain, less expensive drug.
- Quantity limits: plans may limit the amount of drugs they cover over a certain time period, for safety and cost reasons.
- Exceptions: an exception is when a drug plan decides to cover a drug that's not on its drug list, or to waive a coverage rule.
For dry eye, these rules often come up with the newer brand-name drops. Our page on prescription dry eye drops explains what each one does.
02
Who submits a prior authorization?
Usually your eye doctor's office, though you can start it too. For Medicare drug plans, an enrollee, an enrollee's prescriber, or an enrollee's representative may request a coverage decision, which is the formal name for asking the plan to decide.
The request lives or dies on the records. It needs the diagnosis, the findings that support it, the drugs already tried and why they weren't enough. For an exception, the prescriber's letter is required, and the clock doesn't start without it: the adjudication timeframes do not begin until the plan sponsor receives the supporting statement.
03
How long does prior authorization take?
For a Medicare drug plan, days. The plan must give notice of its decision within 24 hours after receiving an expedited request, or within 72 hours after receiving a standard request. An expedited request is for when waiting could seriously harm your health.
Private plans set their own timelines for first requests, and they're stated in your plan documents. The longer delays usually come from missing information, which is why a complete request matters more than a fast one.
A prescription drop doesn't stand in for urgent care, so don't wait on a plan's answer. If your eye is painful, red and getting worse, call your eye doctor the same day, or go to an emergency room when the office is closed. Sudden loss of vision is a 911 call.
04
What is step therapy, and can you skip it?
Step therapy means trying a cheaper drug first. Medicare calls it a type of prior authorization that requires you first to try a certain, less expensive drug, and a plan may ask for it before it covers a newer brand-name drop.
You can ask to skip a step when it doesn't fit you. You or your prescriber can contact your plan to ask for an exception to step therapy, for example when you already tried the cheaper drug, or it isn't safe or right for your eyes. The prescriber's statement explains which.
05
What happens if prior authorization is denied?
You appeal. A denial is the plan's first answer, not its last. For a Medicare drug plan, the plan's written decision will include the information needed to request a redetermination, the first level of appeal.
For private health plans, HealthCare.gov explains the two steps:
- Internal appeal: you must file your internal appeal within 180 days (6 months) of receiving notice that your claim was denied. The plan must finish it within 30 days if your appeal is for a service you haven't received yet.
- External review: an independent reviewer looks at the case, and your insurer is required by law to accept the external reviewer's decision. You have 4 months from the final denial to ask for it.
In California, plans regulated by the Department of Managed Health Care follow their own path. You first file a grievance regarding each issue/request with your Health Plan and take part in it for 30 days, and then you can apply for an Independent Medical Review. If the review overturns the denial, the health plan is required to authorize the services you requested.
06
How to appeal an insurance denial for eye drops
Start with the denial letter, because it names the rule the plan used. Then:
- Read the reason. Missing records, a step not tried and a drug not on the plan's list each need a different answer.
- Ask your eye doctor's office for a letter of medical necessity: the diagnosis, the test results and the drops already tried.
- File on time. For private plans, the Consumer Assistance Program in your state can file an appeal for you, and you can also have your doctor or anyone else file an appeal for you.
- Ask for a faster decision if waiting could harm your eye health.
- If the plan still says no, ask for the outside review your plan or state offers.
Keep copies of everything you send and note each call: who you spoke to and when.
07
How Cohenmehr Optometry handles prior authorizations
We do this work for our patients. At Cohenmehr Optometry, we submit prior authorizations for prescription eye drops, including Miebo, Vevye, Xiidra, Restasis, Cequa and Xdemvy, and we file appeals when a plan denies a drug, a lens or a treatment. We work with Medicare, commercial PPO and HMO plans, and VSP and EyeMed for medically necessary contact lenses.
What helps us most is a complete picture: your plan card, the names of drops you've tried before, and any letters the plan has sent. Our accepted insurance page lists the plans we take, and dry eye care covers the treatments behind these prescriptions.
08
Questions patients ask
Does Medicare require prior authorization for eye drops?
Sometimes, depending on your plan. Medicare drug plans can set rules such as prior authorization, approval based on a plan's specific requirements, and each plan picks the drugs it applies to. If your plan requires it for a drop your eye doctor prescribed, the office sends the request, and you or your prescriber can contact your plan to ask for an exception to prior authorization.
What's the difference between prior authorization and an exception?
Prior authorization is approval to cover a drug under the plan's normal rules. An exception asks the plan to bend a rule: Medicare describes it as when a drug plan decides to cover a drug that's not on its drug list, or to waive a coverage rule. An exception needs your prescriber's supporting statement, and the plan's deadline starts once it arrives.
Can someone else file my appeal?
Yes. HealthCare.gov says you can have your doctor or anyone else file an appeal for you, and the Consumer Assistance Program in your state can file an appeal for you. For Medicare drug plans, an enrollee, an enrollee's prescriber, or an enrollee's representative may request a coverage decision. Our office files these for our patients.
How long does an independent medical review take in California?
Usually about six weeks. The Department of Managed Health Care says IMR cases are generally determined within 45 days of the date the case qualifies, and urgent cases can move faster. You first take part in your plan's grievance process for 30 days. If the review sides with you, the plan must authorize what you asked for.
09
Sources
- Medicare: Drug plan rules
- CMS: Coverage determinations (Medicare Part D)
- HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals
- HealthCare.gov: External review
- California Department of Managed Health Care: Independent Medical Review
Written by
Dr. Kevin Cohenmehr, OD
Medical eye care: glaucoma, diabetic eye exams, macular degeneration and eye infections, plus vision therapy for children. A graduate of UCLA and SUNY College of Optometry.
About Dr. Kevin →



